The EOIR Motion to Reopen Practice Manual
Complete Table of Contents
First Edition · general legal cutoff September 15, 2026. Read a selected passage in the free preview, or start with the practitioner orientation.
Free practice resources include the Chapter 1 decision tree and the EOIR filing fee sheet.
- About the Authoriv
- Forewordv
- Prefacevii
- Acknowledgmentsviii
- Scope and Audiencexiii
- How to Use This Practice Manualxiv
Part One — Foundations
Foundations: the decision tree for choosing the correct reopening path, and the universal motion requirements — statutory and regulatory authority, jurisdiction, deadlines, number limitations, prima facie eligibility, standard of review, stays, service and filing mechanics, and multi-ground strategy.
Chapter 1 — Decision Tree: Choosing the Correct Reopening Path
1- 1.1 Phase 1: Threshold Gatekeeping1
- 1.2 Phase 2: Ground Selection2
- 1.3 Phase 3: Pre-Filing Checklist4
Chapter 2 — Universal Motion Requirements (Legal Framework)
5- 2.1 Statutory & Regulatory Authority5
- 2.1.1 Statutory Framework5
- 2.1.2 Regulatory Framework6
- 2.1.3 Reopening as Disfavored Remedy8
- 2.1.4 Distinguishing Motions to Reopen from Motions to Reconsider10
- 2.2 Jurisdictional Framework14
- 2.2.1 Immigration Judge Jurisdiction14
- 2.2.2 Board of Immigration Appeals Jurisdiction16
- 2.2.3 Consequences of Jurisdictional Error16
- 2.2.4 When Jurisdiction Is Unclear17
- 2.3 Filing Deadlines & Timing18
- 2.3.1 The 90-Day Rule18
- 2.3.2 Statutory Exceptions to the 90-Day Deadline21
- 2.3.3 Equitable Tolling of the 90-Day Deadline23
- 2.4 Number Limitations28
- 2.4.1 The One Motion Rule28
- 2.4.2 Exceptions to the Number Bar29
- 2.4.3 Equitable Tolling of the Number Bar32
- 2.5 Prima Facie Eligibility Standard34
- 2.5.1 Coelho and L-O-G-: Context and Circuit Law35
- 2.5.2 Contexts Where Prima Facie Eligibility Is Not Explicitly Required (But Should Be Addressed)37
- 2.5.3 Building the Prima Facie Record38
- 2.6 Standard of Review41
- 2.7 Stays of Removal42
- 2.7.1 The Governing Principle: No Automatic Stay43
- 2.7.2 Automatic Stay: In Absentia Rescission Motions43
- 2.7.3 Automatic Stay: VAWA Motions44
- 2.7.4 Discretionary Stays Before EOIR45
- 2.7.5 DHS Stay Authority46
- 2.7.6 Federal Court Stays Pending Judicial Review47
- 2.8 Service & Filing Mechanics49
- 2.8.1 Service Requirements49
- 2.8.2 Filing Locations50
- 2.8.3 Electronic Filing50
- 2.8.4 Proof of Filing51
- 2.9 Strategic Considerations in Multi-Ground Motions52
- 2.9.1 Raise All Viable Grounds: The Factual-Consistency Test52
- 2.9.2 Pairing Grounds: What Works and Why52
- 2.9.3 The Supplement Trap: When a Later Filing Becomes a Separate Motion55
- 2.9.4 Structural Requirements for Multi-Ground Presentation56
Part Two — The Motions
The motions: Chapters 3 through 8 develop six reopening grounds on a recurring framework — purpose, threshold screening, strategic risk assessment, required documents and evidence, affidavit guidance, common failure points, and strategic notes. Chapter 9 covers the Calderon Jimenez joint-motion settlement framework, which follows its own specialized structure.
Chapter 3 — In Absentia Motion to Reopen (Improper/Defective Notice)
58- 3.1 Purpose of the Motion58
- 3.2 Threshold Screening: When This Motion Applies59
- 3.3 Strategic Risk Assessment: When NOT to File61
- 3.4 Required Documents and Evidence63
- 3.5 Affidavit Guidance64
- 3.6 Common Failure Points66
- 3.7 Strategic Notes67
- 3.7.1 Service on Minors Under Age 1467
- 3.7.2 Post-Discovery Delay and M-R-A- Diligence Factor68
- 3.7.3 Distinguishing Lack of Notice from Exceptional Circumstances69
- 3.7.4 Post-Departure Filing69
Chapter 4 — In Absentia Motion to Reopen (Exceptional Circumstances)
71- 4.1 Purpose of the Motion71
- 4.2 Threshold Screening: When This Ground Applies71
- 4.3 Strategic Risk Assessment: When NOT to File73
- 4.4 Required Documents and Evidence76
- 4.5 Affidavit Guidance79
- 4.6 Common Failure Points81
- 4.7 Strategic Notes83
- 4.7.1 Ineffective Assistance of Counsel as Exceptional Circumstance83
- 4.7.2 Preserving Timeliness and Stay Protection84
Chapter 5 — Motion to Reopen Based on Ineffective Assistance of Counsel
86- 5.1 Purpose of the Motion86
- 5.2 Threshold Screening: When This Ground Applies87
- 5.3 Strategic Risk Assessment: When NOT to File90
- 5.4 Required Documents and Evidence96
- 5.5 Affidavit Guidance99
- 5.6 Common Failure Points101
- 5.7 Strategic Notes103
- 5.7.1 Lozada Compliance Standard103
- 5.7.2 Prejudice Standard105
- 5.7.3 Constitutional Right to Effective Counsel108
- 5.7.4 Appellate-Stage Malpractice109
- 5.7.5 Post-Departure Filing110
- 5.7.6 Notario Fraud110
Chapter 6 — VAWA-Based Motions to Reopen
113- 6.1 Purpose of the Motion113
- 6.2 Threshold Screening: When This Motion Applies114
- 6.3 Strategic Risk Assessment: When NOT to File117
- 6.4 Required Documents and Evidence120
- 6.5 Affidavit Guidance122
- 6.6 Common Failure Points124
- 6.7 Strategic Notes127
- 6.7.1 Confidentiality vs. Evidentiary Strength127
- 6.7.2 Circuit Variation: Reviewability of Waiver Denials127
- 6.7.3 Combining VAWA with Other Reopening Grounds128
- 6.7.4 Statutory Stay of Removal129
Chapter 7 — General Motion to Reopen Based on New & Material Evidence
130- 7.1 Purpose of the Motion130
- 7.2 Threshold Screening: When This Ground Applies131
- 7.3 Strategic Risk Assessment: When NOT to File133
- 7.4 Required Documents and Evidence135
- 7.5 Affidavit Guidance138
- 7.6 Common Failure Points139
- 7.7 Strategic Notes140
- 7.7.1 General New-Evidence Pathway140
- 7.7.2 Changed-Country-Conditions Pathway147
Chapter 8 — Sua Sponte Motion to Reopen
151- 8.1 Purpose of the Motion151
- 8.2 Threshold Screening: When This Motion Applies152
- 8.3 Strategic Risk Assessment: When NOT to File153
- 8.4 Required Documents and Evidence155
- 8.5 Affidavit Guidance156
- 8.6 Common Failure Points157
- 8.7 Strategic Notes160
- 8.7.1 The Exceptional-Situations Line160
- 8.7.2 Judicial Reviewability: Know Your Circuit160
- 8.7.3 Post-Departure Bar164
- 8.7.4 Change in Law as a Sua Sponte Basis166
Chapter 9 — Calderon Jimenez JMTRD (Time-Limited Class Action Settlement Framework)
168- 9.1 What This Is168
- 9.2 Why This Framework Matters168
- 9.3 Timing Is Critical169
- 9.4 Screening Rules and Submission170
- 9.4.1 Eligibility Screening170
- 9.4.2 Mandatory Post-Dismissal Pathway and OPLA Request Packet171
- 9.4.3 Execution Sequence172
- 9.4.4 Enforcement Procedure174
Part Three — Practice
Practice: evidence assembly and filing mechanics, filing fees and fee waivers, and the companion templates and practice tools. The appendices, Table of Authorities, and Topical Case Index follow as back matter.
Chapter 10 — Evidence Assembly & Filing Mechanics
177- 10.1 Lead with Reopening, Not Merits177
- 10.2 Filing Sequence178
- 10.3 The Evidence Index179
- 10.4 Eliminating Internal Contradictions180
- 10.5 Documenting Timing and Unavailability181
- 10.6 Universal Affidavit Standards182
- 10.7 Translations and Foreign Documents183
- 10.8 Confidential and Sealed Filings184
- 10.9 Assembling Multi-Ground Filings185
- 10.10 Pre-Filing Assembly Checklist185
- 10.11 Incomplete Records and Imminent Deadlines186
Chapter 11 — Filing Fees
188- 11.1 Purpose of the Section188
- 11.2 Default Rule188
- 11.3 Statutory Exceptions to the OBBBA Fee (Only Two)189
- 11.4 Fee Table190
- 11.5 Fee Waivers — Legal Availability and Practical Risk192
- 11.5.1 Presumption of Ability to Pay192
- 11.5.2 Filing Form EOIR-26A192
- 11.5.3 Financial Evidence Supporting the Waiver193
- 11.5.4 Consequences of Fee-Waiver Denial194
- 11.5.5 When to Pay the Fee Rather Than Seek a Waiver194
Chapter 12 — Companion Templates & Practice Tools
196- 12.1 Manual and Companion Package196
- 12.2 How to Access196
- 12.3 A Note on Template Use196
Appendix A — Pre-Filing Assembly Checklist
198Appendix B — Quick-Reference Motion Matrix
199Appendix C — Lozada/Melgar Compliance Checklist
201- C.1 Lozada Three-Prong Requirements201
- C.1.1 Respondent’s Affidavit or Declaration201
- C.1.2 Notice to Prior Counsel201
- C.1.3 Disciplinary Complaint or Documented Explanation202
- C.2 Melgar Heightened Scrutiny203
- C.3 Circuit-Specific Compliance Check203
Table of Authorities
205Topical Case Index
221The Manual, the Template Pack, or both in the Complete Bundle. Compare publications and licenses →